Newcomerstown, Ohio                                     Hometown Archive of Memories
Newcomerstown, Ohio 43832 | The Archives - Everything Newcomerstown

Home | Overview | Historical Timeline | Genealogy | In Memory | Business | Government |Site Index

Sons & Daughters | Military Service | Education | Celebrations | Organizations | Leisure

Nicholas Neighbor and 60 Emigrants
Arrived Here in 1814

The Trip Took Six Weeks

by Anne M. Zimmer

 

 

 

Newcomerstown News: Thursday, August 13, 1964 - In 1764, Delaware Indians occupied the Tuscarawas Valley. Col. Bouquet set out from Fort Duquesne with 1500 soldiers to recover 200 white people taken by the Indians in eastern Pennsylvania. His camp was set up at the forks of the Muskingum River, at what is now Coshocton. The Indians, following the French and Indian War, were beginning to realize they could no longer rely on the French as allies, and recognized the importance of closer cooperation with the settlers to the east.

A Delaware village of 100 houses occupied a site on present routes U.S. 21 and Ohio 16. Chief Netawatwes (Translated Newcomer) lived in the best cabin, which had a board floor, stone chimney and a stairway to the loft. The cleared ground and cornfields south of the river were evidence that the Delawares were industrious. “King” Newcomer felt kindly toward David Zeisberger, a Moravian missionary in the valley. Zeisberger accepted an invitation from the chief to address the tribe, and on March 14, 1771 the first Protestant sermon west of the Alleghenies was delivered to a throng of Indians and about a dozen whites. That location is marked by a monument erected a number of years ago.

Soon after this event, the Delawares abandoned their town and moved to Goshocting (Coshocton).

Little is known of this region during the Revolutionary War, although wandering Indians were said to have occasionally occupied the abandoned cabins. Renegades passed through; Simon Girty and his companions, Brandt and McKee, had a cabin on Buckhorn Creek.

---

At the close of the Revolutionary War, public lands were offered for sale. This area was part of Washington County, where the first settlement had been made at Marietta in 1782 by Revolutionary veterans from Massachusetts who had received grants of land for their services.

One of these tracts, the Stark Patent, lay in this area, in what is now the northeast section of Oxford Township. Its exact limits are not known, but it included the present Schlupp, Watson, Morris, Stahl, and Barnett farms. Since Col. Stark, a resident of New Hampshire never occupied his land, a number of “squatters” took possession, among them families named Carr, Pierce, Funston, Riley, Hartley and Updegraph. Oxford was one of the four original townships in Tuscarawas County when it was organized in 1808.

John Mulvane is known to have been here in 1804, since he had an account at a store of David Peter in Gnadenhutten, and later be bought 100 acres south of the present River Street Bridge.

Before 1800 James Campbell had a trading house in this vicinity, and George Bible was listed as an early resident and hunter. John Douglas was the first Justice of the Peace, in 1808. The first civil case recorded in the county involved David Wolgamot of Oxford Township who was charged with trading three quarts of whiskey to John Jacobs, an Indian, for four deerskins. Since there was a state law forbidding sale of liquor to Indians, he was found guilty, fines $5.00 and ordered to return the skins.

 

---

 

Early landowners in the township were David Johnson who bought 200 acres in 1805 and Daniel Harris, in 1809. John Junkins had a public house 1808 and David Douglass operated a ferry the same year. In 1813 Judge Nicholas Neighbor arrived from New Jersey and bought 1900 acres in the northwest corner of the township.

He returned to New Jersey and came back to Ohio the following year, bringing with him a party of 60 emigrants, almost all of whom were either relatives or neighbors. They spent six weeks making the trip, and on their arrival, lived for a time in the abandoned Delaware cabins. Judge Neighbor’s cabin, the first erected, was located immediately south of the present railway station. George Bible, already an “old settler” got acquainted with the Neighbor family by placing a freshly killed deer in front of their door. It frightened the newcomers at first, but provided them with their first venison.

Appointed as associate judge, Nicholas Neighbor lived for a number of years at New Philadelphia and was one of those who presided in the autumn of 1825 at the trial of the murderer of the postboy. This crime occurred in Oxford Township and the guilty man, John Funston, was hanged and brought for burial to his parents’ home on the Stark Patent. Judge Neighbor later returned to Newcomerstown, and died here.

 

---

 

Andrew Creter came from New Jersey in 1817 and soon after his arrival married Judge Neighbor’s daughter, Elizabeth. When his wife died, he returned east and brought back his sister, Sarah, who reared his family of four children, one of whom was Jack Creter - last of his father’s family - who built the large house at the corner of Bridge and Church Streets, now owned by Russell Taylor.

 
Related Links: Link 01, Link 02, Link 03  

Share Your Own Comments About This Page 

 

Site Map | FAQ | Policies | Participate | Contact

© Newcomerstown.us - Newcomerstown.com - Newcomerstown.org - Newcomerstown.info - Newcomerstown.net. All Rights Reserved.

Website Design & Development by Almond Didier Art & Design